WI Cormorant Research Group Study | Cormorant databases - Great cormorant | last updated on 02-01-2002 |
Fish species recognised in the food in Europe
after
Cormorants
Phalacrocorax carbo
in Europe
a first step towards a European management plan (2.
draft)
The National Forest and Nature Agengy, Denmark
&
The National reference Centre for Nature Management, The
Netherlands
Many prey fish species have been recognised in diet studies. Appendix reviews and lists the fish species eaten by Great cormorants in Europe. At least 115 fishes were recognised at the species level in the food of European cormorants. In most areas only a few species are staple food. Table 4 reviews the most important prey species found in diet studies.
Summary of the predominant prey fish of Great cormorants in Europe (modified after Marquiss & Carrs 1994 and Keller & Vordermeier 1994). P = pellet analyses; R = regurgitated food remains; S = analyses of stomachs of shot or drowned birds; V = . | ||||
Location |
Months | Method | Prey | Reference |
Marine sea coast | ||||
SW England | X-II | S | flounder, plaice, dab | Steven 1933 |
E Denmark | IV-VII | S | eel, eelpout, herring, cod | Madsen & Spark 1950 |
E Denmark | IX-XII | S | eel, cod, eelpout | Madsen & Spark 1950 |
W Ireland | VIII-XII | S | pollack, herring | Piggins 1959 |
NE England | VI-XI | R, S | flatfish, gadoids, eel | Pearson 1968 |
E Scotland | VI-VII | R, P | dab, saithe, eelpout | Mills 1969 |
E Scotland | VII-XII | S | flatfish, gadoids, clupeids | Rae 1969 |
Ireland | VI | R | wrasse, eel, flatfish | West et al. 1975 |
W Sweden | VI | P | wrasse (3 sp), cod | Härkönen 1988 |
E Denmark | V-IX | P | dab, eelpout, cod | Härkönen 1988 |
E Finnmark | VII | P | gadoids, capelin | Barret et al. 1990 |
W Norway | VII | P | gadoids | Barret et aI. 1990 |
W Norway | IX-X | P | gadoids | Barret et al. 1990 |
W Russia | IV-VIII | P | gadoids, clupeids | Bianki et al. 1993 |
N Germany | VII-IX | V | eelpout | Kieckbusch 1993 |
The Netherlands | VIII | P | plaice, flounder, sole, dab | Van Damme 1994a |
The Netherlands | VII-VI | P | flounder, eel, dab, plaice | Boudewijm et al. 1994 |
Helgoland | IX-V | P | bull rout, cod | Van Damme 1994b |
Denmark | II-IX | P | sea scorpion, dab, eelpout, cod | Hald-Mortensen 1994 |
Denmark | III-X | P | dab, cod, flounder, eelpout | Hald-Mortensen 1995 |
Estuary | ||||
W Ireland | V-VII | S | brown trout, eel | Piggins 1959 |
Scotland | ? | S | flounder, sea trout | Mills 1965 |
NE Scotland | IX-VI | S | flounder, saithe | Rae 1969 |
N Italy | X-II | P | sand smelt, mullet, sea bass | Boldreghini et al. 1993 |
Rivers | ||||
Scotland | ? | S | trout, salmon, flounder | Mills 1965 |
SE Scotland | XI-III | S | grayling, roach, salmonids, flounder | McIntosh 1978 |
N Ireland | V | S | brown trout, salmon | Kennedy & Greer 1988 |
Switzerland | X-III | P | grayling, brown trout | Suter 1991 # |
Switzerland | X-III | P | roach, chub | Suter 1991 # |
Austria | XII-II | P | grayling, nase | Schratter & Trauttmansdorff 1993 |
Austria | XII-II | P | roach, bream chub/dace, ruffe, perch | Schratter & Trauttmansdorff 1993 |
Austria | XII-II | R | roach, bream | Schratter & Ttrauttmansdorff 1993 |
Austria | XI-II | P | bullhead, roach, Leuciscus sp., perch | Zuna-Rratky & Mann 1994 |
SW Scotland | III-IV | S | flounder, trout, roach, perch | Carss & Marquiss ? |
SE Scotland | II-IV | S | grayling, trout | Carss & Marquiss ? |
N Scotland | IV-V | S | salmon, trout | Carss & Marquiss ? |
Freshwater lakes and lochs | ||||
NW England | XI-III | S | char, perch, brown trout | Hartley 1948 |
The Netherlands | III-VII | R | roach, eel, ruffe, pikeperch, bream | Van Dobben 1952 |
Scotland | ? | S | brown trout, perch, salmon | Mills 1965 |
The Netherlands | IV-VII | R | bream, eel, pikeperch | De Boer 1972 |
Ireland | IX-IV | P | roach, perch | MacDonald 1987 ?? |
The Netherlands | IV-VII | P | ruffe, smelt, rvach | Voslamber 1988 |
N Germany | VII-XI | P | perch | Worthmann & Spratte 1990 |
The Netherlands | X-III | P | ruffe, perch, pikeperch, cyprinids | Marteijn & Dirksen 1991 |
Switzerland | X-III | P | roach, perch | Suter 1991 |
The Netherlands | III-VII | R | roach, bream, eel | Veldkamp 1991 |
NE Poland | IV | S | roach, eel, tench, bream, pike | Mellin & Martyniak 1991 |
NE Poland | IV-VII | P | roach, eel, perch, bream | Mellin & Martyniak 1991 |
Hungary | ? | R | carp, eel | Gere & Andrikovics 1992 |
The Netherlands | XI-IV | P | roach, perch, ruffe, pikeperch | Platteeuw et al. 1992 |
The Netherlands | XIII-IX | P | perch, ruffe, amelt, roaeh | Middendorp 1993 |
The Netherlands | I-XII | P | roach, bream, perch, pikeperch | Veldkamp 1994 |
The Netherlands | IV-VII | R | roach, bream, pikeparch, perch | Veldkamp 1994 |
The Netherlands | IV-V | P | roach, ruffe, perch, smelt | Nienhuis 1995 |
Stocked lochs | ||||
Scotland | III | S | rainbow trout | Carrs & Marquiss (unpub.) |
E Scotland | I-III | S | trout | Carrs & Marquiss (unpub.) |
Fish farm ponds | ||||
S France | ? | ? | carp | Im &.Hafner 1984 |
The Netherlands | ? | ? | carp, graas.carp | Moerbeek et al. 1987 |
Czech Republic | III-XI | R | carp | Musil et al. 1995 |
NE Poland | S, P | carp | Mellin et al. ? | |
Fish farm cages | ||||
W Scotland | IX-III | S | rainbow trout (escaped) | Carss 1993 |
Compared to the total number of fish species found in the food of cormorants, the number of species thait either by mass or number "really matter" is relatively small.
In freshwater habitats about 24 fish species are important:
Eel, bream, white bream,.barbel Barbus barbus, crucian carp C. carassius, nase Chondostoma nasus, carp Cyprinus carpio, chub Leuciscus cephalus, ide Leuciscus idus, roach, rudd, tench, pike Esox lucius, smelt Osmerus eperlanus, whitefish Coregonus sp., rainbow trout, salmon, brown trout,grayling Thymallus thymallus, burbot Lota lota, three-spined stickleback Gasterosteus aculeatus, ruffe, perch, zander and flounder.
The predation on about 12 species interferes or might interfere with human commercial catches:
Eel, carp, whitefish, rainbow trout, salmon, brown trout, grayling, perch, tench, pike, roach, and zander.
In salt water habitats c. 15 fish species are important either by number or by weight:
Eel, herring, capelin Mallotus villosus, cod Gadus morhua, whiting Merlangius merlangus, haddock Melanogrammus aeglefinus, three-spined stickleback, bull-rout Myoxocephalus scorpius, sea bass,Viviparous blenny Zoarces viviparus, butterfish Pholis gunellus, black goby, plaice Pleuronectus platessa, dab and flounder.
In Mediterranean salt water habitats the following fisches seem to be important prey for the cormorant: grey mullets Mugilidae (in particular Liza ramada), sand-smelt Atherina sp., sea-bass Dicentrarchus sp. and Labridae.
Interference with human commercial yields might exist amongst:
Eel, cod, sea-bass, dab, flounder, gilthead, mullets.
In marine habitats interactions between human fisheries and the cormorants'fishing might occur only in the coastal zone. In Denmark, where, sinensis predominantly feeds in marine habitats, the cormorants catch of the commercially valuable dab reaches up to 50% of the human catch in the same area. However. the cormorants catch consists of far smaller fish than the human catch. In general; compared to human catches, cormorants at sea take only insignificant quantities of commercially important fish species.
In the Mediterranean salt water interference with human yields may exist with regard to mullets and Dicentrarchus. in artificial lagoons interference with commercial production might exist with regard to eel, mullets, sea bass and gilt-head (Génard et al. 1993).